You are here

Board Oversight

board_oversight.jpg

Highlights of the Boards’ oversight activities

Boards of Governors

The Boards of Governors of the African Development Bank (ADB) and the African Development Fund (ADF) are the highest decision-making organs of the Bank Group. With representation from all the Bank Group’s 81 member countries, the Boards of Governors executed their mandate with the support of six subsidiary organs (Figure 4.1): the Bureau, the Joint Steering Committee, the Steering Committee on the Election of the President of the Bank, the Standing Committee on the Conditions of Service of Elected Officers, the Governors’ Consultative Committee (GCC), and the Ad Hoc Committee on the Reform of Governance Instruments (Ad Hoc Committee).

Work of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Boards of Governors

Established in the last quarter of 2020 to oversee and guide the review of certain governance instruments of the ADB Group, the five-member Ad Hoc Committee of the Boards of Governors held nine meetings in 2022.

The Ad Hoc Committee presented a final report on its activities to the Boards of Governors at the 2022 Annual Meetings. The Governors adopted the report, which proposed amendments to the Code of Conduct for Board Officials and the Whistleblowing Policy (the “Draft Governance Instruments”). They endorsed the general orientations in the Draft Governance Instruments and referred them to the Boards of Directors for finalization and adoption by year’s end. They also adopted the provisions uniquely relating to the President of the Bank Group contained in the Draft Governance Instruments. And they directed the Boards of Directors to undertake a comprehensive and holistic review of the independence of key oversight functions of the Bank Group, within the Group’s ongoing work on institutional reforms, and to submit a report on progress made at the next Annual Meetings scheduled in May 2023.

The 2022 Annual Meetings

The 57th Annual Meeting of the Board of Governors of the ADB and the 48th Annual Meeting of the Board of Governors of the ADF were held jointly in Accra in a hybrid format from 23 to 27 May 2022, under the theme “Achieving Climate Resilience and a Just Energy Transition for Africa.”

The Boards of Governors adopted the Annual Report and Audited Financial Statements for the financial year ended 31 December 2021. In addition, they adopted Resolutions on the following:

  • General Election of the Executive Directors of the ADB.
  • Selection of the Executive Directors of the ADF.
  • Appointment of Deloitte & Associates as External Auditors for the Financial Years 2022 through 2026.
  • Distributions of Allocable Income of the African Development Bank for the Financial Year ended 31 December 2021.
  • Distribution of Part of the Income of the Nigeria Trust Fund for the Financial Year ended 31 December 2021.
  • Annual Report and Audited Special Purpose Financial Statements for the Financial Year ended 31 December 2021.
  • Conditions of Service of Elected Officers: Comprehensive Review of the Remuneration of the President and Executive Directors.
  • Reforms of Certain Governance Instruments of the African Development Bank and African Development Fund.
  • Election of the President of the African Development Bank—Electronic Voting.

Governors’ dialogue

At the 2022 Annual Meetings, the Governors discussed the continent’s most pressing challenges and opportunities, focusing on the strategic positioning of the Bank Group over the next 10 years to build a “prosperous Africa, based on inclusive growth and sustainable development.” The President highlighted 10 areas that will be critical in defining the new Ten-Year Strategy for the Bank Group: Africa’s economic growth and recovery; Lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic; Relevance of the High 5s; Climate change and the role of the Bank Group; Energy and a just energy transition; Infrastructure; Fragility and insecurity; Strengthening the African Development Fund; Inclusive growth, Women and youth; and Economic governance and long-term financial sustainability.

The Governors:

  • Acknowledged that the High 5 priorities—Light Up and Power Africa, Feed Africa, Industrialize Africa, Integrate Africa, and Improve the Quality of Life for the People of Africa—remain relevant in the strategic orientation of the Bank Group over the next 10 years, particularly in the context of selectivity and the Bank’s comparative advantage.
  • Agreed with the 10 areas highlighted by the President as the basis for the next Ten-Year Strategy taking into consideration the current exogenous shocks caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine,14 and the resulting food crisis that required short-term and medium-to-long-term strategies to deal with the resulting multifaceted challenges facing the continent.
  • Called for sustained efforts toward addressing the challenges of climate change through mitigation and adaptation and by adopting approaches that ensure a just transition to clean, renewable, affordable, reliable, and sustainable energy services while ensuring energy security and sustainability. In this regard, while welcoming the alignment of the Bank Group’s activities with the Paris Agreement through the recently adopted Climate Change and Green Growth Strategic Framework, the Governors called for an ambitious revision to the energy policy.
  • Underscored the importance of the Bank Group’s financing of healthcare infrastructure in line with the Bank’s comparative advantage to enhance Africa’s preparedness for and resilience to future pandemics, including supporting the development of quality healthcare infrastructure on the continent and fostering partnerships to build the capacity of the pharmaceutical industry to manufacture vaccines and therapeutics.
  • Welcomed efforts to strengthen the standalone credit rating of the Bank and ensure the financial sustainability of the Bank Group and the mobilization of innovative financing through mechanisms such as hybrid capital, public-private partnerships, balance sheet optimization, and other co-financing and risk-sharing arrangements. In this vein, the Governors also welcomed efforts being made by the Bank to explore options for the strategic use of Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) to support Africa, including the channeling of SDRs on a voluntary basis from advanced and emerging economies that can do so through the Bank Group, as a prescribed holder, to leverage the resources to provide greater financing to African economies.
  • Underscored addressing the root causes of fragility and providing adequate resources to fragile countries in recognition of the 50th anniversary of the ADF. In this vein, Governors called for a substantial and transformative ADF-16 replenishment. They welcomed the ongoing discussions among ADF Deputies on the possibility of the ADF being allowed to go to the market to leverage its equity and raise additional resources to offer at affordable rates to Africa’s low-income countries while providing incentives for countries that graduate from the ADF.
  • Called for sustained efforts toward inclusive development through interventions that promote gender equality and inclusiveness for women, support youth through job creation, and increase access to finance for youth entrepreneurship initiatives.
  • Underscored policy and economic governance reforms to boost domestic resource mobilization, transparent natural resource management, economic diversification, human capacity development, private sector–led growth, and digitalization. Governors also highlighted sound debt management practices to ensure transparency and accuracy in the reporting of debt. Governors further called for the timely implementation of the G-20 Common Framework for Debt Treatments beyond the Debt Service Suspension Initiative (DSSI) and urged eligible Regional Member Countries (RMCs) to continue to apply to the Framework, while calling for effective coordination among creditors.
  • Reiterated the importance of regional integration and the critical role of the Bank supporting the African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA), which has the potential to play a catalytical role in integrating the continent and enhancing inter-African trade and the continent’s sustainable development.

Mandate and composition of the resident Boards of Directors

The resident ADB and ADF Boards of Directors guide the strategic direction and general operations of the Bank Group pursuant to powers delegated by their Boards of Governors. The Bank’s Board of Directors has 20 members, with 13 representing the 54 RMCs, and 7, the 27 non-regional member countries. The Fund’s Board of Directors has 14 members, with the Bank and the ADF state participants, each designating 7 members. Executive Directors serve as shareholder representatives to the Bank Group and work to advance its development mission in their constituent countries.

Strategic direction to the organization: Institutional reforms, effectiveness, and results

In 2022, the Boards of Directors provided strategic direction toward addressing the continent’s development challenges, including the Bank’s implementation of the reform commitments undertaken as part of the 7th General Capital Increase (GCI-VII) and the African Development Fund’s 15th Replenishment (ADF-15). They approved the following items:

  • Allocation of Shares Under the Share Transfer Rules: Shares Available for the Period ending 22 December 2021.
  • African Emergency Food Production Facility (AEFPF) to address the looming food crisis in RMCs as a result of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
  • Cost Containment Framework.
  • Review of the Cost-to-Income Ratio.
  • 2021 Review of the Sovereign Loan Pricing.
  • Issuance of up to UA 3 billion in hybrid capital to strengthen the Bank’s financing capacity.
  • Establishment of the Africa Circular Economy Facility (ACEF) multi-donor trust fund.
  • Establishment of the Public Finance Management Academy for Africa (PFMA).
  • Establishment of the African Pharmaceutical Technology Foundation (APTF).
  • Extension of the ADB’s Mandatory Retirement Age from 62 to 65.
  • Revisions to the Financial Regulations of the ADF.
  • Revisions to the Financial Regulations of the ADB.
  • Room to Run Sovereign—A Public-Private Capital Recycling Transaction.
  • A new Code of Conduct for Board Officials.
  • A new Whistleblowing and Complaints Handling Policy.
  • Performance-Related Remuneration for 2021.

The Boards reviewed and cleared several documents for consideration by the Boards of Governors, including the Resolutions adopted at the Annual Meetings and documents for information such as the Third Progress Report on the Implementation of the GCI-VII Commitments; Optimizing the Financial Strength and Capacity of the African Development Bank; the Independent Recourse Mechanism’s 2021 Annual Report; the Bank’s Water Sector Activities and Initiatives in 2021; and the African Union’s New Partnership for Africa’s Development Infrastructure Program’s Annual Report 2021.

The Boards also provided strategic and institutional direction to ensure delivery of the High 5 priorities, with an emphasis on sustainable development, inclusive growth, and concrete impact on the lives of beneficiaries in RMCs. The Boards approved strategies, policies, loans, grants, equity investments, guarantees, the 2023–2025 work program and budget document, and the 2023 borrowing program of the ADB. In all, the Boards approved 121 projects, totaling UA 6.117 billion. Some 58 percent of these projects (14 percent of the amount) were approved through the lapse-of-time procedure, and 42 percent (86 percent of the amount were approved in plenary sessions. (Highlights of these approvals are in Chapter 2.) In addition, Senior Management approved technical assistance and other activities amounting to UA 38.6 million.

Consultative missions and study tours

The Executive Directors undertook consultative missions to Nigeria, Morocco, and the Republic of Congo to engage governments, development partners, the business community, and civil society on the quality and relevance of the Bank’s country strategies; the socioeconomic and political challenges facing the countries, as well as the efforts of the respective governments to tackle them; the benefits of the Bank’s presence and the condition and status of Bank Group operations in the countries; and the Bank Group’s contribution to donor coordination and implementation of the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness. In the same vein, Senior Advisers and Advisers to Executive Directors undertook study tours to Lesotho and Rwanda to assess the progress of Bank Group–financed projects.

Standing committees of the Boards of Directors

The Boards worked through eight standing committees, including the new Ad Hoc Committee on the ADF Governance Framework toward Increasing Regional Member Countries’ Voice and Contribution, added in 2022, to which they delegate certain responsibilities (Figure 4.2 and Appendix 9). These committees conduct close reviews of matters in their areas of competence and make recommendations to the Boards as appropriate. Each committee also oversees the performance of the organizational units related to its responsibility.

Independent evaluation of Bank Group interventions

Throughout 2022, Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV)’s active engagement with Bank stakeholders, including Senior Management and task teams, ensured that important evaluative knowledge was being leveraged. For example, the new Bank Group Strategy for Addressing Fragility and Building Resilience in Africa (2022–2026), approved in March 2022, was strongly informed by the learnings from IDEV’s 2020 evaluation of the Bank’s previous Fragility Strategy (2014–2019) and its evaluation of the Transition Support Facility. Likewise, the Bank’s new Private Sector Development Strategy and its Framework for Public–Private Partnerships, both approved in January 2022, were informed by IDEV evaluations, as was the Sustainable Borrowing Policy, approved in February 2022.

In 2022, IDEV delivered 11 evaluation products (Figure 4.3). Five Regional Member Countries (RMCs) benefited from an IDEV evaluation of support by the Bank for their development programs, among which one impact evaluation. The Bank’s overall support to its RMCs was covered by one project cluster evaluation, one sector evaluation, and the biennial synthesis report on the validation of Project Completion Reports and Expanded Supervision Reports. Strategically, the Bank benefited from two corporate evaluations and an evaluation synthesis.

Knowledge-sharing efforts were closely aligned with the Bank’s focus on climate resilience, just energy transition, and food security: IDEV contributed to the AfDB Governors’ Digest and produced a background paper for COP27 as well as lessons learned note to inform the Board of Directors’ discussion of the African Emergency Food Production Facility. The 2022 edition of IDEV’s flagship event, the AfDB Development Evaluation Week, attracted over 800 online participants.

In 2022, evaluation capacity development was high on IDEV’s agenda. The team responded to various demands by organizing eight targeted training programs for IDEV staff and a number of dialogue and learning forums. IDEV further extended its technical support to the Global Evaluation Initiative, EvalPartners, Twende Mbele, the Evaluation Platform for Regional African Development Institutions, and the African Parliamentarians’ Network on Development Evaluation.

Compliance, accountability, and intermediate recourse mechanisms

Compliance

Compliance review and mediation

In 2022, the Independent Recourse Mechanism (IRM) handled a total of 16 active complaints submitted by Civil Society Organizations and Project Affected Persons for projects in the transportation (8), power (4), agriculture (2), water supply, and sanitation (2) sectors. In addition, the IRM supported institutional learning with an advisory note on Preventing, Mitigating, and Responding to Sexual Exploitation, Abuse and Harassment within AfDB operations, as well as a preliminary draft on retaliation risk assessments. In partnership with the Arab Watch Coalition, Accountability CounLesson sel, and West Africa Civil Society Institute, IRM engaged with Civil Society Organizations in North Africa and Francophone West Africa through virtual and hybrid outreach events on issues of accessibility to the mechanism and identifying obstacles to effective remedy for people affected by ADB-funded projects.

Ethics

In 2022, the Ethics Office handled 176 requests for guidance and conducted series of trainings on the Bank’s Code of Ethics for all categories of staff and fiduciary clinics in some of the Bank’s Country Offices. It participated in meetings, conferences, and professional activities of heads of ethics from inter-governmental institutions, multilateral development banks, and the United Nations. It acquired a new web-based reporting and case management system known as Ethics Point to facilitate reporting, enhance confidentiality, and improve results. It also revamped its intranet-based microsite to include documents relating to ethics, such as the Bank’s Code of Ethics, the Ethics 101 Awareness Series, communication materials on the Sexual Exploitation, Abuse and Harassment campaign, and annual reports of the Ethics Office, for ease of consultation by employees.

Accountability and control

Audit

During 2022, the Office of the Auditor General transitioned from a remote working posture to a mixture of hybrid and on-site audit inspections. It focused on delivering 48 internal audit assignments, providing assurance across a wide range of both developmental and corporate Bank activities. It also organized a forward-looking off-site retreat with the theme “Build on firm foundations to deliver greater value addition to the Bank.” The actions noted for implementation included improving reporting and strengthening communications and client relationships. Many of the initiatives have been operationalized.

Integrity and anti-corruption

In 2022, a total of 92 Integrity Risk Opinions were issued, covering 48 proposed non-sovereign operation transactions valued at UA 2 billion and 44 other Bank activities and operations such as Anti- Money Laundering/Combating the Financing of Terrorism. The Office of Integrity and Anti-Corruption (PIAC) also issued 46 Integrity Risk Advisories. PIAC initiated the tracking of recommendations for the implementation of due diligence opinions on a quarterly basis to increase the Bank’s monitoring of integrity opinions. As part of the Bank’s participation in the MDBs’ Mutual Enforcement of Debarment Decisions, PIAC debarred 154 entities in 2022. During the year, the Bank supported 21 debarred entities to enhance their Integrity Compliance Programs as a condition for release from debarment. In addition, PIAC completed 39 Sanctionable Practices representing 58 percent of the case pipeline at the end of 2022. This led to the filing of 8 Findings of Sanctionable Practices, 2 Negotiated Settlement Agreements, and 4 Appeals. A new trend of cases received in 2022 was related to cyber security and phishing and was swiftly investigated to protect the Bank. Regarding staff misconduct, 17 of 21 of cases in the pipeline were completed.

Recourse mechanisms

Office of the Ombudsman

The Office of the Ombudsman (SNOM) carried out its key activities on Conflict Management and Mediation and successfully dealt with 62 cases. Of those, 43 originated from Headquarters and 19 from Region and Country Offices. Nine cases are ongoing, 3 have been referred to the appropriate units, and the remaining 50 were dealt with and closed within 4 weeks. The cases fell into the following categories: Policy (24 percent), Conduct & Abuse of Power (24 percent), Separation (7 percent), Career Development & Job Security (31 percent), Performance Management (5 percent), Benefit and Compensation (6 percent), and Other Issues (3 percent). The Bank-wide 12th Annual Conflict Competency Week was held from 25 to 28 October 2022 with the theme “The Future of Work: Growing Your Team Brand” as the Ombudsman’s Office marked its 30th Anniversary. SNOM participated in the 17th Annual Conference of the International Ombudsman Association and the 19th United Nations and Related Heads of International Organizations Conference.

Administrative Tribunal

In 2022, the Administrative Tribunal registered 11 new applications, heard 10 cases, and issued 9 judgments and 1 order. The Administrative Tribunal held 2 judicial sessions and 1 plenary session in 2022, during which 10 applications were decided: 2 cases from 2022, 6 cases from 2021, and 2 cases from 2020 that had been re-opened after a first judgment.

Staff Appeals Committee

The Staff Appeals Committee was replaced by the Staff Grievance Committee (STAGRICO) effective October 2022. The new Rules of Procedure and the Presidential Directive N°06/2022 brought important changes to the peer review mechanism, which will lead to applications before STAGRICO being handled significantly more quickly. STAGRICO heard three applications in 2022 and registered an additional three, which involved issues of non-confirmation of probation, contested performance evaluation ratings, and contestation of a warning letter. These changes will streamline the grievance procedure and make it more efficient, less litigious, and more cost-effective for the benefit of all staff members.

Sanctions Commissioner’s Office

In 2022, the Sanctions Commissioner reviewed nine cases, including six formal sanctions cases, two Negotiated Settlements Agreements (NSAs), and one Request for temporary suspension. All these cases involved Sanctionable Practices in connection with the procurement of works and services (3) and execution of contracts (6), involving six projects financed in six RMCs. The Sanctionable Practices are related mostly to fraud (7) and fraud and obstruction (2). A final determination was issued on the Request for Temporary Suspension, and the two NSAs were cleared, concluding a conditional non-debarment for 24 months for one respondent and a letter of reprimand for the other. Five formal sanctions cases were concluded, resulting in four sanctions decisions and the closure of one case pending a preliminary action by PIAC. The sanctions decisions declared four firms and one individual ineligible to participate in activities financed and managed by the Bank Group for periods ranging from 18 months to 4 years.

Sanctions Appeals Board

In 2022, the Sanctions Appeals Board Secretariat issued Decision No. 9 for an appeal filed in 2021 and prepared two appeals that were reviewed separately by the Board. Decisions No. 10 and 11 are pending publication. In addition, the Secretariat received two new appeals in late 2022 that will be reviewed in 2023. As part of the exchange knowledge program, harmonization of definitions, and improvement of sanctions systems within MDBs, the Secretariat actively participated in virtual workshops and conferences with other Sanctions Appeals institutions.

Last updated: 06-Jul-2023