You are here
Sanctions Procedures

Prior to the conclusion of an investigation, or when submitting formal sanctions proceedings to SNSO, PIAC may request a temporary suspension of the subject of the investigation or sanctions proceedings (the “Respondent”) from participating in Bank Group-financed activities and from being awarded new contracts. Such a request may be made if PIAC believes that continued eligibility of the entity would pose an imminent risk of financial or reputational harm to the Bank Group. This measure is intended to serve as a safeguard to protect the Bank Group from potential financial or reputational damage.
To grant the temporary suspension, the Sanctions Commissioner will consider a number of factors, including: the imminent financial or reputational harm to the Bank; the urgency of the request; the description of the ongoing and outstanding investigation; and finally, whether there is sufficient evidence to support the likelihood that the Respondent engaged in a Sanctionable Practice, for which an appropriate sanction would be no less than a one (1) year debarment.
Under the sanctions process, PIAC refers cases to SNSO with a recommendation that the Sanctions Commissioner imposes sanctions on the Respondent alleged to have engaged in one or more Sanctionable Practices. These cases are dealt with through an administrative process consisting of written exchanges submitted by PIAC and the Respondent to SNSO.
PIAC’s contentions, arguments and evidence are compiled in a file referred to as “Findings of Sanctionable Practices” (the FoSP). The Sanctions Commissioner reviews the FoSP and assesses the evidence supporting the allegations of Sanctionable Practices. This prima facie determination is based solely on the evidence provided by PIAC. Where the Sanctions Commissioner considers that the allegations are not supported by sufficient evidence, he/she will issue a Determination of Insufficient Evidence, ending the procedure. If, on the contrary, the Sanctions Commissioner considers that the evidence is sufficient, he/she will issue a Notice of Sanctions Proceedings (the Notice) to the Respondent, inviting the Respondent to present its arguments in defence (the Response).
Upon receipt of the Response, the Sanctions Commissioner will review the entire file and determine, based on the preponderance of the evidence, whether it is more likely than not that the Respondent committed the alleged misconducts. If the answer is in the negative, the Sanctions Commissioner will withdraw the Notice. Otherwise, the Sanctions Commissioner renders a Sanctions Decision and imposes on the Respondent one or more of the sanctions defined in the Sanctions Procedures.
The Sanctions Decision is final and binding unless a Respondent refers the matter before the Sanctions Appeals Board (SAB) within sixty (60) calendar days from the date of notification of the Sanctions Decision.
In relation to a negotiated settlement agreement concluded by PIAC with a Respondent to solve an allegation of Sanctionable Practice, PIAC will first submit the agreement to the General Counsel of the Bank Group. The latter will review and ensure that the terms of the agreement are in conformity with the Sanctions Procedures and any applicable Bank Policy.
PIAC will then submit the agreement to the Sanctions Commissioner who verifies the fairness, transparency, and credibility of the agreement and ensures that the sanctions imposed are proportionate to the seriousness of the infringement(s) and that the Respondent has entered into the agreement freely, and fully informed of its terms. The agreement cleared by the Sanctions Commissioner becomes binding on both parties.
The Sanctions Commissioner may impose the various sanctions, the predominant one being the debarment of entities or individuals, who as a result will be ineligible for a fixed or indefinite period to participate in or benefit, directly or indirectly, from any of the Bank Group’s financed activities. Sanctions may also be imposed on executive officers and associated parties of a sanctioned firm. Sanctioned entities and individuals are included in the list of debarred entities.
The Sanctions Commissioner may impose:
- Letter of reprimand: Formal letter of censure for the Respondent’s actions. The letter notifies the Respondent that subsequent violations may result in a higher penalty.
- Conditional non-debarment: The Respondent is required to take certain remedial or preventive measures within a specified period to avoid debarment by the Bank.
- Temporary Debarment: The Respondent is debarred for a specific period of time.
- Debarment with conditional release: The Respondent is debarred for a specific period and will be released from debarment after the debarment period lapses and only when the Respondent has demonstrated that the conditions for release are met.
- Debarment for a fixed or indefinite period: The Respondent is debarred permanently.
- Restitution of funds and/or other financial remedies: The Respondent will make refunds or pay other financial remedies.
- Other sanctions: The Respondent will reimburse totally or partially the costs associated with the investigation or proceeding.
The summaries of the Sanctions Decisions are publicly disclosed.
Multilateral Development Banks are convinced that a unified and coordinated approach is critical to the success of their efforts to fight corruption. Therefore, the African Development Bank, the Asian Development Bank, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, the Inter-American Development Bank, and the World Bank Group signed on 9 April 2010, the Agreement for Mutual Enforcement of Debarment Decisions. Pursuant to this Agreement, a debarment decision taken by a signatory of the Agreement, may be applied by the other signatories, under specific conditions.
Practically, the Bank Group may cross debar and declare ineligible, parties sanctioned by the other signatories of the Agreement, for a minimum period of one year + one day. Similarly, the other signatories of the Agreement may cross debar parties debarred by the Bank Group, for the same minimum period.